Infant industry argument 4 for this argument to be valid, the return in the grown up industry must be sufficiently to offset the higher prices paid by domestic consumers of the commodity during the infancy period. Learningbydoing and infant industry protection i assume that the infant industrys dynamic learning occurs through learningbydoing. One of the most notable arguments for protection is known as the infant industry an industry, most often in a developing country, that cannot compete in international markets in free trade but that, if given time to learn and develop, could be worldclass efficient. A thesis on the rationales of import substitution industrialization strategy by hong liang isbn. In particular, there are very few studies on the policy on japanese automobile industry in the prewar period. The key element of the infant industry argument is the presence of a positive dynamic production externality. This test is applied for the first time to test if the protectionism takes the form of an infantindustry protection. Infant industry argument, protection and manufacturing. Revisit contentse791ea8c1a5e4e8db74aa3043620a9b8%404 macroeconomic policy around the world for more information on the infant industry argument. One rationale for the infant industry argument is that, by protecting domestic firms from foreign competition, this increases rents and investment in innovation and other growth enhancing measures.
The main economic argument against infant industry protection is that protection is likely to be a secondbest policy choice rather than a firstbest policy. The infantindustry theory is the supposition that emerging domestic industries need protection against international. World economy infant industry argument 1 infant industry argument the infant industry argument suggests that an industry may be developed under the umbrella of the governments temporary protection. The proposed reappraisal of the infant industry idea is based on the classical principle of comparative advantage, but places the argument in the dynamic context of modern theories. The infant industry argument is when there are substantial economies of scale in an industry fixed costs, and such industry can not exist and compete against foreign competition because they do not have the scale to produce at the low cost foreign industry can. The basic rationale behind the argument is that the new industries.
When countries restrict trade in a number of areas they may be protecting industry, but theyre also being antiglobal. Download limit exceeded you have exceeded your daily download allowance. Can i make the infant industry argument but unironically. Though a logically tight case for infant industry protection has never. Liberalization and firm performance 11 access to technology 11 access to capital. Because he wants readers to make their own informed decisions, they and ed must grapple with sunk costs, opportunity costs, present value, factor mobility, dumping, tariffs, quotas, voluntary restraint agreements, the infant industry argument, the national security argument, industrial policy, the rise of the service sector, income inequality, the causes of the japanese catchup, how to. Its main contribution is to show that list recommended selective, rather than acrosstheboard, protection of infant industries and that he was against neither. Later on, friedrich list published his book, national system of political economy, in 1841, which helped refine, formulate, and provide a comprehensive overview of the. Empirical studies of the infant industry argument have given an impression that there is not much maturation of infants in very many developing countries bell et al. The classical view on the argument seems too static and too restrictive, whereas the modern approaches fail to provide a convincing theoretical framework. From infant industry protection to fdiled industrial takeoff, columbia fdi perspectives, no. The infant industry argument supports trade protectionism. The learning coefficients are estimated by fitting both the cobbdouglas and the c. The economic argument against infant industry protection.
The core of the argument is that nascent industries often do not have the economies of scale that their older competitors from other countries may have, and thus need to be protected until they can attain similar economies of scale the argument was first fully articulated by alexander hamilton in his 1790 report on. Infant industry protection an overview sciencedirect topics. The international economics study center trade chapter. His single industry model has since been extended to analyze. Evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of the infant. In general, neoclassical economics accepts the validity of infant in dustry argument but.
Although frowned upon by the world trade organization in this. The infant industry theory is the supposition that emerging domestic industries need protection against international competition until they become mature and stable. The infant industry argument relies on a dynamic view of the world rather than the static description used in classical trade models. Empirical record for infant industry protection 5 inhibited gains 5 unintended politicaleconomy consequences 7 foregone comparative advantage 8 conclusion 9 3.
In the 1970s and the 1980s, the argument had receded into the background following its influential critiques by trade economists james meade, harry johnson and. Governments are sometimes urged to support the development of infant industries, protecting home industries in their early stages, usually through subsidies. I argue that if tariffs cause exports flow, the economy implement a protection following lists principles. Some important papers that explicitly take into account learning effects include baldwin and krugman 1986, 1989, hansen, jensen, and madsen 2003, head 1994, irwin 2000, and luzio and greenstein 1995. These arguments are based around industry and competition, environmental concerns, and issues of safety and security.
Perspectives on the chinese large civil aircraft industry book january 2014 with 781. Presents a comprehensive exposition of various possible bases for an infant industry argument for protection. The following is table 2 from the infant industry argument. Columbia fdi perspectives perspectives on topical foreign.
Infant industry argument financial definition of infant. Showed next 250 characters if you cannot find any suitable paper on our site, which happens very rarely, you can always order custom written paper which will be written from scratch by our professional writers and deliver to you on requested time. In examining the infant industry argument at work, we dont just want to know how cotton spinning in the french empire fared during the blockade. Infant industry protection and trade liberalization citeseerx. Infant industry argument definition, rationale and. Infant industry argument flashcards and study sets quizlet. Higher learning coefficients in the case of pakistan than those observed in. If labor is abundant in southlandia but capital is scarce, when southlandia opens to trade. Download fulltext pdf download fulltext pdf the wto and infant industry promotion in developing countries. Overall, the empirical evidence and its interpretation support the revisionist rather than neoclassical or market friendly view in the recent debate on east asian industrialization. A reexamination of the infant industry argument for protection. The infant industry argument for protectionism is that small domestic industries need to be temporarily nurtured and protected from foreign competition for a time so that they can grow into strong competitors. May 05, 20 the infant industry argument will complain that, in such cases, if the businesses involved were just given extra profits through tariffing their foreign competition, they could pay for the labor. The infant industry argument was initiated by alexander hamilton in 1791 when he argued for the protection of industries in the united states from imports from great britain.
Although protection may be detrimental to national welfare in the short run, it is conceivable that the positive dynamic longrun effects will more than outweigh the shortrun or static effects. Using data on 4,750 firms across developing countries, we examine whether protection via tariffs or nontariff measures sps and tbt specifically. The learning coefficients estimated for pakistan corroborate the infant industry argument. Though a logically tight case for infant industry protection has never been made, proprotection authors have claimed its truth since at least its statement by alexander hamilton in 1791.
Pdf the wto and infant industry promotion in developing. Japan achieved import substitution of trucks before world war ii. Govers 2012 therefore, a second best alternative can be introduced which examines the rate of productivity growth of the protected industry while drawing a comparison with unprotected industries in other countries bell et al. I employ the granger causality test to determine the nature of swiss protectionism during the first wave of globalization 188619. Accordingly, infant industry promotion and protection is necessary. An infant industry is one which is newly established in a country.
Apr 18, 2014 for these reasons the infant industry argument is often criticized. Learn infant industry argument with free interactive flashcards. Such a policy must weigh the future cost savings of an industry in which dynamic economies of scale are present with the. Protectionist reasoning that industrial startups need safeguards against established foreign manufacturers and cutthroat competitors, especially in developing economies. According to the infant industry argument many developing. A reexamination of the infant industry argument for. The infant industry argument is an economic rationale for trade protectionism. First, it explores the origin of lists theory by giving a general explanation and some background information, by identifying the pattern of protection and by examining the justification for his theory. This test is applied for the first time to test if the protectionism takes the form of an infant industry protection. Govers the infant industry argument 4 founding of the infant industry argument and discusses the historic example of infant industry protection during the industrial revolution. It shows that static economies of scale have a doubtful.
This protection is commonly sought by enacting high import duties andor import quotas. Download the pdf in this post and policy report at the marshall institute,the author contends that the necessity of government production subsidies for renewable energy on the basis on the infant industry argument, which argues that government. Infant industry argument a policy position stating that new industries developing in a country need government protection. Choose from 92 different sets of infant industry argument flashcards on quizlet. The core of the argument is that nascent industries often do not have the economies of scale that their older competitors from other countries may have, and thus need to be protected until they can attain similar economies of scale. It distinguishes dynamic internal economies and dynamic external economies and, in the latter case, reciprocal external economies, and externalities resulting from labour training, knowledge diffusion, and atmosphere creation.
For these reasons the infant industry argument is often criticized. Arguments for and against protectionist policy boundless. Pdf an empirical test of the infant industry argument. The main economic argument against infant industry protection is that protection is likely to be a secondbest policy choice rather than a firstbest policy choice. The infant industry argument iia, initially devised by alexander hamilton in 1791 and friedrich list in 1841 hoekman, 2001, p.
Doc infant industry argument karen enriquez academia. What are the main causes and effects of economic protectionism. According to the strategic trade policy, it is argued that by appropriate actions, a government can help raise national income if it can somehow ensure that the firm or firms. An empirical test of the infant industry argument the basic infant industry argument maintains that. This paper analyzes the effect of policies on the japanese automobile industry before 1945.
In economics, an infant industry is a new industry, which in its early stages experiences relative difficulty or is absolutely incapable in competing with established competitors abroad. The implication of the infant industry argument as played out in this example is that country a reduces trade with country b. There are very few detailed evaluations of infant industry protection. Govers 2012 therefore, a second best alternative can be introduced which examines the rate of productivity growth of the protected industry while drawing a comparison with unprotected industries in. His single industry model has since been extended to analyze the consequences of learning in more than one industry. This study supports infant industry argument validity by showing successful. Answer keys to the problem sets are avalable in adobe acrobat pdf format for easier viewing and printing.
A popular argument against freer trade is that infant industries1 in developing countries2 cannot compete against foreign. In economics, an infant industry is a new industry, which in its early stages experiences relative difficulty or is absolutely incapable in competing with established competitors abroad governments are sometimes urged to support the development of infant industries, protecting home industries in their early stages, usually through subsidies or tariffs. The infant industry argument is theoretically possible, even sensible. For new industries, it almost impossible for a new startup to compete against a wellestablished industry unless they have a unique differentiation in their product. The infant industry argument 1 static arguments 1 dynamic arguments 2 counterarguments 3 2. The paper then discusses probable factors that have made the maturation and growth of infant industries possible in korea. The infant industry argument a is based on the belief that. Reprinted with permission from the vale columbia center on sustainable international investment. The argument claims that protection is warranted for small new firms, especially in lessdeveloped countries. The infant industry argument is one of the oldest arguments used to justify the protection of industries from international trade. Its argued by some economists that problems with the infant industry argument arise at this point. The infant industry argument iia, initially devised by alexander hamilton in 1791 and friedrich.
Feb 20, 2007 this paper analyzes the effect of policies on the japanese automobile industry before 1945. Some clarifications on the infant industry argument unctad. According to the infant industry argument, developing countries suffer dynamic losses from free trade by specializing according to their comparative advantage on sectors with poor dynamic learning externalities. A new empirical test of the infantindustry argument.
In 1791, alexander hamilton suggested that assuring protection to domestic entrants could preempt entrydegterrence by foreign firms. Principles of microeconomicsarguments in support of. Infant industry argument argument that industries in the developing and emerging sectors of the economy need protection against international competition in order to establish themselves. Pdf why have most cases of infantindustry protection. A downfall of the infant industry argument is that o nce established, a tariff is politically difficult to remove. Infant industry protection and trade liberalization. Ozawa, the role of multinationals in sparking industrialization. The infant industry argument and renewable energy production. To allow manufacturing to get a toehold, the argument is that governments should temporarily support new industries until they have grown strong enough to meet international competition. The infant industry argument based on this type of learning externality was. The infant industry argument and dynamic comparative advantage. In addition, infant industry protection can be a virtual solution to market failure which may impedes the establishment of such industry. A the antidumping argument b the infant industry argument c the strategic industry argument d the sunset industry argument 30 a large amount of the agricultural products in a country were damaged by floods. In the process of the development of automobile industry, the government policies seemed to have both positive and negative effects.
This essay aims to examine friedrich lists theory of the infant industry argument in detail. The main argument for protectionism is that of infant industry. Although, the substantiation of embryonicinfant industries is found within the mercantilism thesis, hamilton is. From the point of infant industry argument, the prewar period is more important because japan nurtured the automobile industry from zero and achieved importsubstitution of. When and how should infant industries be protected. The infant industry argument and dynamic comparative. Pdf download for a reexamination of the infant industry argument for. Aug 28, 2012 the first set of causes are mainly mercantilist, and include the infant industry argument, spillover effects, national security, the unequal exchange perspective, fair trade and state interests divergent from global income maximization. From a broader and more farreaching perspective, protectionism as a general principle has been heavily criticized even in infant industry situations. Publications the infant industry argument and renewable. The infant industry argument will complain that, in such cases, if the businesses involved were just given extra profits through tariffing their foreign competition, they could pay for the labor. The infant industry argument based on this type of learning externality was first explicitly modeled in a dynamic framework by bardhan 1971. Download the pdf in this post and policy report at the marshall institute,the author contends that the necessity of government production subsidies for renewable energy on the basis on the infant industry argument, which argues that government support and protection of. The argument is that free markets add value on a global level, while protectionism confines economic value to the nation employing it.
1304 872 402 6 803 1143 249 1568 1051 1068 464 676 770 624 370 1197 140 853 863 1105 1275 307 1222 362 665 909 1230 449 839 471 1446 205 1052 498 1350 1474 425 651 910